Court of Appeals of Oregon February 22, 1982, LUBA No. 80-171, CA A21137 (Ron Jones & Co. v. Faye Wright Neighborhood Planning Council)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-1982

ROBERTS, J., Pro Tempore.

This is a case challenging the City of Salem’s issuance of a variance for construction of a cul-de-sac street 300 feet longer than the 800-foot limit imposed by Salem Revised Code 63.225(c). The issue has twice been before the Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA). LUBA first held the variance invalid, declaring the city’s findings were inadequate to demonstrate compliance with the criteria set forth in Salem Revised Code 63.332(a).1 The city then reconsidered and granted the variance again, supporting it this time with more detailed findings. LUBA again reversed, finding no substantial evidence to support those findings. We affirm.

The city’s findings focus on the unreasonable hardship which would be imposed upon the developer by requiring him to abandon the plan for extending the cul-de-sac street and to acquire off-site property for access to a public street. While the record supports a finding that this alternative would work a financial hardship on the developer, this is not the issue the city was required to consider. To justify the granting of a variance, the applicable ordinance requires, inter alia, a finding that “[t]here are special conditions inherent in the property * * * which would make strict compliance with a requirement of SRC 63.115 to *7363.265 an unreasonable hardship. * * It was therefore incumbent upon the city to find that strict compliance with the relevant ordinance, i.e., construction of a cul-de-sac no more than 800 feet in length, would work an unreasonable hardship. There is nothing in the evidence taken at the October, 1980, hearing, or in the records of the earlier hearings, which the city incorporated into its second decision, to support a finding that construction of only an 800-foot cul-de-sac to serve the property would be an unreasonable hardship.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.