Court of Appeals of Oregon December 15, 1982, No. E-7451, CA 17866 (Minter-Wilson Drilling Co. v. Richins)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1982
lead-opinion
BUTTLER, P. J.
Plaintiff commenced this action to foreclose a construction lien for labor performed and material supplied in well-drilling activities pursuant to two contracts. Defendants Paul H. Richins, Richtron, Inc. and Richtron Financial Corporation (Richtron Financial) appeal from a judgment against them and Merrill Glenn, foreclosing plaintiffs lien against real property in which they were alleged to claim an interest, the fee title of which is apparently in Glenn, who has not appealed. The appealing defendants, hereafter referred to collectively as defendants, assign the following errors: (1) failure to dismiss plaintiffs lien as untimely filed; (2) denial of their motion for dismissal on the grounds that plaintiff failed to show its corporate existence and lacked clean hands; (3) failure to limit the lien to the particular property benefitted by the work performed; (4) entry of judgment against defendant Richins and Richtron Financial, in the absence of proof that they had any interest in the land, and (5) awarding attorney fees in an excessive amount and in disregard of plaintiffs failure to give the required statutory notice to defendants. We modify the decree as hereafter set forth.
BACKGROUND
On November 22, 1977, plaintiff, a well-drilling corporation based in Garden City, Kansas, entered into a written contract with “Catlow Valley Farms” to drill a minimum of ten irrigation wells and test holes on land purportedly under the control of Catlow in Harney County. The contract was signed by plaintiff and by “Catlow Valley Farms by Richtron, Inc., Paul H. Richins, President.” Evidence concerning the legal status or existence of Catlow Valley Farms is sparse. Richins, the moving force behind the irrigation project, testified that Catlow is “the sum of seven different limited partnerships” based in Ogden, Utah.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit