Louisiana Court of Appeal April 13, 1982, No. 13774 (Tucker v. Lirette)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-04-1982

ELLIS, Judge:

This case is before us for the purpose of fixing damages following a remand from the Supreme Court. See Tucker v. Lirette, 393 So.2d 293 (La.App. 1st Cir. 1980); Tucker v. Lirette, 400 So.2d 647 (La.1981).

The injuries suffered by plaintiff Walter Dale Tucker were the result of an accident on April 23, 1978, when his motorcycle struck an automobile operated by Mrs. Earl Lirette, Jr. and insured by State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company. Defendants are Mrs. Lirette, her husband, and State Farm.

Mr. Tucker suffered numerous contusions and abrasions over his body, some minor lacerations, and a compound fracture dislocation of his right wrist. Dr. Pete H. Rhymes, an orthopedist who was the treating physician, testified that a laceration on the back of plaintiff’s head was sutured, and the others cleaned up. He stated that the fracture was not a bad one. Some severed tendons were repaired, and the break was set with a pin. Plaintiff remained in the hospital for six days. Dr. Rhymes stated that the injury was extremely painful for two or three days, and that plaintiff suffered some pain thereafter for two or three weeks.

*558Plaintiff wore a long arm cast until May 22, 1978, when it was replaced with a short arm cast, which was, in turn, removed on June 5th. The pin was removed from plaintiff’s wrist on June 15th and he began physical therapy on June 29th. By August 9th, x-rays showed the fracture to be well healed and in good position, with some narrowing of the wrist joint near the fracture site. Plaintiff demonstrated a lack of grip strength in the right hand.

Dr. Rhymes was of the opinion that plaintiff had a 15% to 20% disability of the wrist as a result of the accident. Although plaintiff made no complaints of pain in the wrist after May, 1978, the doctor felt that the narrowing of the wrist joint foretold that plaintiff might develop wrist arthritis at some later date.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.