District Court of Appeal of Florida September 10, 1982, No. AG-303 (Gentzel v. Estate of Buchanan)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1982

SHIVERS, Judge.

Appellant Gail Gentzel, daughter of the decedent Alma B. Buchanan, appeals the probate order determining that a' savings and loan association savings account, a commercial bank certificate of deposit, a commercial bank savings account, and a commercial bank checking account, all in the joint names of appellant Gentzel and decedent, are probatable assets of the decedent which pass under the decedent’s will rather than to the appellant Gentzel as surviving account holder. The trial court found that these joint accounts were really the property of the decedent, that the presumption in law favoring the daughter was rebutted by the daughter’s own testimony that she considered the questioned assets to be the decedent’s property that it is clear it was the intention of both the daughter and the decedent that the accounts were opened and maintained for the benefit of the decedent, and that the daughter had no interest in the accounts.

Appellant contends the trial court erred by failing to apply section 665.271, Florida Statutes (1979) and section 659.291, Florida Statutes (1979) to the facts of this case.1

We conclude the trial court correctly applied these statutes to this case and there is *367competent evidence upon which to affirm the trial court’s order.

The decedent Alma B. Buchanan died testate March 17, 1980. Except for a few items of personal clothing and jewelry which she bequeathed to her daughter, the decedent devised her entire remaining estate to her two children, John G. Buchanan and the appellant, Gail B. Gentzel, in equal shares.

The decedent had been badly injured in an automobile accident in 1967 and from the time of her husband’s death in 1974, decedent was maintained in nursing homes in Pennsylvania, California and Florida. She did not reside with her daughter or with her son.

It was dangerous for decedent to walk by herself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.