Louisiana Court of Appeal August 31, 1982, No. 13237 (Brown v. Celotex Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1982

lead-opinion

SCHOTT, Judge.

In this worker’s compensation case the extent of plaintiff’s disability is the principal issue. He has appealed from the judgment of the trial court awarding benefits for partial disability under LSA-R.S. 23:1221(3) contending that he is entitled to benefits for permanent total disability under § 1221(2). The defendants, his employer and the employer’s insurer, have answer*207ed the appeal seeking a limitation of recovery to that for a scheduled disability for the loss of an arm under § 1221(4)(f). Plaintiff also seeks penalties and attorney fees based upon defendants’ arbitrary and capricious termination of compensation benefits, and defendants contend that an award of $254 of medical expense incurred by plaintiff with Dr. Gordon Nutik was improperly awarded to plaintiff.

Plaintiff was employed by Celotex Corporation as a common laborer and suffered an injury on the job on February 17, 1977, when he fell down and struck his left shoulder on a piece of metal. He was placed on maximum compensation from that time until September 15,1978, when the compensation was reduced to $30 per week where it remained until March 25, 1980, when compensation benefits were terminated. The first reduction was based on a report to defendants by Dr. R. E. Horn, Jr., who gave him a 20% partial, permanent disability of the left upper extremity at that time. The termination of benefits was based on a report of February 12, 1980, by Dr. R. C. Grunsten that there was no reason why plaintiff could not participate in daily laboring activities, although he might have some difficulty in full overhead elevation of the extremity with force.

Following his injury, plaintiff was treated by Dr. Horn, an orthopedic surgeon. He diagnosed a left shoulder cuff tear which he treated conservatively until March 15 when it was surgically repaired.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.