Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama October 12, 1982, 7 Div. 881 (Parker v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-1982

TYSON, Judge.

Thomas Edward Parker was indicted for the murder of Helen McCarter by shooting her with a gun in violation of § 13A-6-2, Code of Alabama 1975. The jury found the appellant “guilty of manslaughter” and the trial court set sentence at ten years’ imprisonment in the penitentiary.

Because reversible error appears through the exception to the trial court’s oral charge, we pretermit consideration of the evidence in this cause.

I

In the trial court’s oral charge we find the following statement: (R. 305).

“While the Court determines the volun-tariness of a confession, the jury determines its weight or credibility and may disregard any alleged statement which is unworthy of belief or in which they entertain a reasonable doubt as to its truth.”

Defense counsel excepted to this part of the oral charge as follows: (R. 309).

“MR. PARKER: Well, we first except to the statement by the Court that the Court determines the voluntariness of a confession and I except to the use of the word, ‘confession.’

“I realize that it was a statement that was introduced into evidence but it was not, and the reading of it could not be considered a confession.” '

Mr. Justice Lawson in McPhearson v. State, 271 Ala. 533, 540, 125 So.2d 709 (1960) made the following observation:

“No confession from the defendant was introduced in evidence. The defendant at all times professed his innocence. His testimony, as well as the statements made by him which were introduced by the State, show that he claimed the shooting was an accident.

“The admissibility of confessions and in-culpatory admissions are generally determined under the same principles. But *853there is a broad distinction between admissions of inculpatory facts and confessions of guilt. When a person only admits certain facts from which the jury may or may not infer guilt, it is no confession.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.