Louisiana Court of Appeal September 30, 1982, No. 13076 (Porrovecchio v. Salathe Oil Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-09-1982
GULOTTA, Judge.
Defendants, appealing, claim an $18,-000.00 general damage award for a “garden variety soft-tissue injury” of the neck and back “of several months duration” is excessive.
This matter was submitted on plaintiff’s testimony and that of an investigating officer, together with a hospital report and reports of an orthopedic surgeon and a neurologist.
In written reasons, the trial judge concluded that plaintiff had sustained various injuries, “the most serious being a severe cervical strain which caused him to miss a substantial amount of work and incur various medical expenses”. He awarded the following special damages, which are not in dispute.
Doctor Bills $960.00
Auto Rental 586.52
Pharmacy and Medication 89.23
Hospital Expenses 256.50
Lost wages 10,625.00
TOTAL— $12,517.25
Finally, the trial judge concluded that the injuries were “painful” and of a “constant nature”.
Joseph Porrovecchio, forty-three years of age at the time of the September 20, 1979 accident, sustained head, neck, shoulder and lower back injuries when his automobile was rear-ended by a truck driven by defendant, Larry J. Adler. According to Por-rovecchio’s testimony, within “a couple of hours” after the accident, he went to the emergency room at Jo Ellen Smith Hospital because of headaches and back pain. Following examination, a “neck brace” was prescribed, and plaintiff was released the same day.
On September 25, 1979, plaintiff saw an orthopedist, Dr. R.E. Horn, Jr., who found decreased range of motion of the cervical spine with spasm and tenderness in neck and shoulder muscles on both sides. X-rays of the cervical spine were negative. Dr. Horn’s diagnosis was “cervical strain”. Pain killing medication was prescribed with instructions for “mild neck exercises”.
On September 26, plaintiff saw Dr. Horn again with continued complaints of pain and a more potent pain reliever was prescribed. On October 12,1979 plaintiff complained to Dr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit