District Court of Appeal of Florida October 29, 1982, No. AC-261 (Publix Supermarkets, Inc. v. Kostrubanic)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-10-1982

WENTWORTH, Judge.

Petitioner seeks review of an order of the deputy commissioner requiring it to produce for inspection by the deputy copies of all written and recorded statements taken from “all witnesses in this cause.”1 The order states that the deputy will deliver to the claimant’s attorney “those portions of said statements in which witnesses indicate what the claimant said to them.” We reverse.

The order was entered after a hearing on claimant's motion to produce. At the hearing the deputy stated on the record the parties’ positions as follows:

We are also hearing argument that certain statements, recorded statements given by employees of the Employer be furnished to the Employee. And I’m going to state on the record the position of the parties subject to addition and correction by the parties.

Mr. Edwards has asked that these be produced; Mr. Guant feels that these items are work product. Mr. Edwards, I believe, agrees that they’re work product, but he’s asking for an exception to the general rule because the expense of trying to take the depositions of the parties to get the same information that could be obtained merely by copying portions of these statements would be excessive, especially in relation to the amount of benefits that can be anticipated to be obtained in this case, [e.s.]

Petitioner argues (1) that the deputy erred in requiring production of the statements because claimant did not comply with the applicable rules2 requiring a showing that he could not obtain the substantial equiva*53lent of the materials by other means without undue hardship; and (2) that review of the order (prior to the deputy’s inspection and designation of discoverable items) is not premature because the deputy is the trier of fact as well as law, and his inspection of such material as may be privileged would therefore involve risk of extra-evi-dentiary bias independent of the alleged error in any order ultimately entered for delivery of portions to claimant’s attorney.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.