Louisiana Court of Appeal November 16, 1982, No. 82 CA 0054 (Gardner v. Allstate Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1982

LEAR, Judge.

This action arises from an automobile accident on August 8, 1979,1 in which a truck driven by an insured of defendant-appellee, Allstate Insurance Company, came into contact with an automobile driven by plaintiff-appellant, Marian R. Gardner, while both vehicles were being parked at a private residence. This suit was instituted for damages purportedly sustained as a result of this contact.

Trial was held before a jury, and verdict was rendered in favor of defendant-appel-lee. Judgment was signed accordingly, from which plaintiff-appellant has timely perfected this appeal.

The facts concerning the manner in which the accident occurred are disputed, and the jury’s finding of fact is raised as the issue on appeal.

Immediately prior to the accident appellant had opened her door and placed one foot on the ground; as a result, when contact was made with the insured’s vehicle, appellant’s leg was trapped in the door frame. The primary issue at the trial con*1381cerned the manner in which the contact between the vehicles was made, there being considerable conflict in the testimony as to what happened in the parking area.

It was established that appellant was in the process of getting out of her parked car when her car door was struck by the truck driven by the insured. Appellant contended that appellee’s insured backed into her while she was leaving her vehicle. Appellee contended that appellant opened her door into the path of an already moving vehicle.

Appellant’s testimony at trial conflicted with a prior version related by her in a deposition, and a passenger in appellant’s car also testified at the trial at variance to facts related in her deposition. Although these variations in the testimony related to the relative positions of the vehicles and not as to the resulting collision, defense counsel used these inconsistencies in characterizing appellant’s credibility.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.