District Court of Appeal of Florida December 16, 1982, Nos. AF-372, AF-373 (Davis v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1982

PER CURIAM.

The Duval County Grand Jury returned two indictments1 against appellant, Davis, charging violations of Florida’s theft stat*876ute, Section 812.014, Florida Statutes2. A jury found appellant guilty of both charges. We reverse.

In October of 1980, appellant was employed as City Manager of the City of Atlantic Beach. During that month, he attended the Florida League of Cities Convention with the members of the City Commission, including Commissioner/Mayor Howell. All of these individuals planned to spend time at the convention working for the election of Mayor Howell as President of the Florida League of Cities. In anticipation of the expense of such a campaign, both the Mayor’s and the City Manager’s expense accounts had been increased from $1,200.00 each to $1,500.00 each for the 1980 budget year.3 In preparation for the trip, appellant and each commissioner received per diem and mileage checks. Appellant received $377.20 representing his per diem and mileage for the trip. One hundred thirty-seven dollars and twenty cents ($137.20) of this amount represented mileage. Appellant requested and received an additional twelve hundred dollars ($1,200.00) from the City Comptroller, Mrs. Tucker.

THE MILEAGE CHECK

Mileage and per diem expenses for travel by City of Atlantic Beach employees are governed by resolution. Prior to 1980 these amounts were set by resolution 72-8,4 *877which purported to bring the amounts paid and reporting requirements in line with those established for state employees.5 Evidence at trial showed that this resolution was amended in 1980 by resolution 80-66 because the amounts reflected in resolution 72-8 were no longer adequate due to the effects of inflation, and because state reporting requirements were seen as too strict.7

Immediately prior to the trip Mrs. Tucker computed the mileage involved and prepared checks for the commissioners based on the mileage and per diem figures set out in resolution 80-6.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.