United States Bankruptcy Court, S.D. Florida. January 12, 1982, Bankruptcy No. 76-380-Bk-JE-B; Adv. No. A (Hemmerle Industries, Inc. v. Walter Kassuba Realty Corp. (In re Kassuba))
Also known as
United States · · · 12-01-1982
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
THOMAS C. BRITTON, Bankruptcy Judge.
In this involuted case, the debtor-in-possession, Kassuba, obtained a judgment for over $680,000 against K. V. Hemmerle and others on February 13, 1980. (C.P.No. 285a). A year later, Kassuba obtained a judgment that Hemmerle Development Corporation, a Florida corporation, is an alter ego of K. V. Hemmerle. (C.P.No. 429a). On March 25, 1981, Kassuba garnished Landmark Bank, which acknowledged an indebtedness to Hemmerle Development Corporation in the sum of $100,736 but alleged that third parties, D. J. Morgan and W. D. Ryan have an interest in that account. These third parties were implead-ed nine months ago. They have answered, claiming ownership of one-half of the funds in the account.
Garnishment in aid of a bankruptcy judgment is governed by local law. B.R. 769. The applicable state statute, § 77.16, Florida Statutes, provides that if a third party claims garnished funds by affidavit (which was done in this instance, C.P.No. 530):
“... the court shall impanel a jury to determine the right of property between the claimant and plaintiff unless a jury is waived.”
Instead, Morgan and Ryan moved for summary judgment (C.P.No. 530) to recover the one-half claimed by them. The motion was heard on January 6, 1982.
It is undisputed that the account was opened on March 3, 1981 by a deposit of $100,000 made by Bramalea, Inc., with explicit instructions to clear the funds and pay one-half jointly to Morgan and Ryan and the remainder to Hemmerle Development Corporation “in the event no claims have been filed against this fund within three months from the date hereof.” No claims were filed other than this writ of garnish*701ment. It is also undisputed that no judgment exists reflecting any indebtedness by either Morgan or Ryan to the debtor.
The instructions directed the bank “to place the funds in the registry of the court having jurisdiction” in the event a claim is filed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit