United States Court of Military Appeals December 6, 1982, No. 40,047; SPCM 14212 (United States v. Cherry)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-12-1982
Opinion of the Court
PER CURIAM:
The Court granted review of three issues in this case:
I
THE MILITARY PANEL WHICH TRIED THE APPELLANT WAS IMPROPERLY CONSTITUTED.
II
THE MILITARY JUDGE ERRED IN GIVING THE STANDARD “REASONABLE DOUBT” INSTRUCTION CONTAINED IN THE MILITARY JUDGES’ GUIDE RATHER THAN THE INSTRUCTION PROPOSED BY THE DEFENSE (APPELLATE EXHIBIT IV).
III
THE MILITARY JUDGE ERRED IN REFUSING TO GIVE A SELF-DEFENSE INSTRUCTION ON CHARGE II, SPECIFICATION I (ASSAULT).
Our answer to the second granted issue is determinative in this case and requires reversal of the decision of the United States Army Court of Military Review.
The defendant pleaded guilty to one specification of failure to repair, in violation of Article 86, Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 U.S.C. § 886. Another failure-to-repair specification was dismissed on motion of trial counsel. All the remaining *252charges and specifications concerned incidents that occurred on the 26th day of April 1979, while the accused was enroute to and at the firing range. The record reveals that these charges were keenly contested. The accused pleaded not guilty to all of these charges, presented three witnesses, and took the stand in his own behalf to contest the Government’s evidence. The Government had presented its evidence from four witnesses. The accused was acquitted of five of the nine offenses that were sent to the jury.1
The trial defense counsel objected to the reasonable-doubt instruction2 offered by the trial judge. Not only did counsel object, but he proffered in substitution an instruction that did not equate “reasonable doubt” with “substantial doubt.” The trial judge declined the proffered instruction. This was error. United States v. Salley, 9 M.J. 189 (C.M.A.1980).
In United States v. Brooks, 11 M.J. 420 (C.M.A.1981), a majority of this Court formally announced that the rule for prejudice stated in United States v. Cotten, 10 M.J. 260 (C.M.A.1981), was retroactive.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit