District Court, N.D. Texas March 12, 1982, Civ. A. Nos. CA 4-81-284-E, CA 4-81-286 (Texas Steel Co. v. Donovan)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1982

ORDER

MAHON, District Judge.

There is pending before the Court plaintiffs motion to compel answers to interrogatories and to require production of documents and subpoenaed materials. After careful review of said motion and the parties’ briefs, the Court makes the following ruling.

I. Statement of Facts.

Plaintiff, Texas Steel Company owns and operates a manufacturing facility and is engaged in interstate commerce and is located in Fort Worth, Texas. On May 7, 1980, defendant, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) received a safety complaint from the president of the union representing employees at plaintiff’s Fort Worth facility. This complaint apparently related to the stacking of steel rebars in the outdoors shipping area of plaintiff’s plant. Based upon this complaint OSHA decided to inspect plaintiff’s plant. On May 13, 1980, Mr. Scott, an OSHA compliance officer, sought voluntary entry of plaintiff’s plant. Plaintiff denied Mr. Scott entry, and informed him that plaintiff would assert its right to be subjected to an inspection only after the issuance of a properly obtained search warrant. Mr. Scott obtained further evidence of the violation, and on June 2, 1981, OSHA agents made an ex parte application to United States Magistrate Alex H. McGlinchey for a search warrant. On that same date, Magistrate McGlinchey did issue such a warrant.

On June 10,1981, OSHA compliance officer Henry Slagle presented the warrant at plaintiff’s plant. Plaintiff’s attorney read the warrant and claimed that he was unable to make a reasoned assessment of the grounds for the warrant, and therefore refused to allow Slagle to enter.

On June 12, 1981, defendants responded to plaintiff’s refusal by filing an action to have plaintiff held in contempt of court. On that same date plaintiff filed the present suit claiming that the search warrant was invalid and that the regulation allowing defendants to obtain an ex parte warrant was invalid.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.