District Court, S.D. New York December 17, 1982, No. 81 Civ. 6241(MEL) (Sparta Florida Music Group, Ltd. v. Chrysalis Records, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1982

LASKER, District Judge.

This action involves a dispute over the rights to royalties from the sale of a “hit” record. Sparta Florida Music Group, Ltd. (“Sparta”) claims that the author of the song, John Holt, assigned to it all of his rights to proceeds from the song. Sparta then licensed Chrysalis Records, Inc. (“Chrysalis”) to manufacture the records and remit royalties to Sparta. Chrysalis has not remitted royalties to Sparta because two other companies, Push Music Publishing Co. (“Push”) and B & C Music Co. (“B & C”) are also asserting rights to the royalties. B & C and Push have been joined in the action by interpleader.

*46Push asserts that Holt wrote the song with two other individuals, Howard Barrett and Tyrone Evans, and that Barrett and Evans assigned their rights to proceeds from the record to Push. B & C claims that Holt assigned his rights to the record to B & C prior to the time that he made the assignment to Sparta. Barrett, Evans and Holt were at one time members of the same singing group in Jamaica. Currently, they are all residing in New York. (Affidavits of Barrett and Evans.)

Chrysalis concedes its liability for the royalties and has been paying the sums in question into the registry of the Court pending adjudication of the question as to whom they are due.

Sparta moves to dismiss the action without prejudice pursuant to Rule 41(a)(2) or, in the alternative, in accordance with the doctrine of forum non conveniens. Sparta contends that the action should be conducted in Great Britain, because Sparta, B & C and Push all do business in Great Britain, and none do business in New York. Also, one of the facts giving rise to the action took place in New York. Sparta also contends that certain of its witnesses reside in Great Britain.

B & C and Push answer that Barrett and Evans are in New York and cannot afford to travel to Great Britain to litigate. Sparta replies that their testimony can be preserved by deposition.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.