Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit September 2, 1982, No. 81-3055 (Tacynec v. City of Philadelphia)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-09-1982
OPINION OF THE COURT
ADAMS, Circuit Judge.
This case concerns the First Amendment rights of string bands to perform in Philadelphia’s Mummers Parade and the proper standards to be used in evaluating the constitutionality of the Parade Rules. In 1981, the City adopted rules to limit the number of bands that could participate in the parade. The plaintiffs are two string bands and their founders, who would be excluded from marching by these Rules, unless a current parade participant does not march. They filed this action in the district court alleging that the regulations unconstitutionally inhibited their First Amendment freedoms of expression and association. The district court struck down the Rules as an invalid infringement of the bands’ freedom of expression and therefore did not reach the freedom of association claim. Because we find that the district court did not apply the proper test in judging the Rules, the case will be remanded both for reconsideration of the free expression claim as well as a determination of the freedom of association claim.
I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
One of Philadelphia’s well-established traditions is its annual Mummers Parade on New Year’s Day. The parade includes thousands of participants, and draws many times that number of spectators. In recent years, the parade has ended after dark, thus creating serious safety and traffic hazards in the city. The parade is arranged and administered jointly by the Philadelphia Shooters and Mummers Association, a private organization, and the Recreation Commissioner of the City of Philadelphia.. The Commissioner determines which groups may participate in the parade.
An important division of the parade consists of the string bands, units containing between 48 and 64 paraders performing music primarily on string, reed and percussion instruments, wearing elaborate original costumes and presenting a special theme.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit