Colorado Court of Appeals October 20, 1983, 83CA0135 (In Re the Marriage of Flohr)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1983

ENOCH, Chief Judge.

In this garnishment proceeding, garnishee, Empire Savings and Loan, seeks a reversal of the trial court judgment entered in favor of Jacob Flohr, garnishor. We affirm.

Jacob Flohr sought to enforce a judgment obtained against Marie Flohr by serving a writ of garnishment on Empire. At the time the writ was served on Empire, Marie Flohr had a revocable savings account trust with Empire, which had been in existence before Jacob Flohr became a creditor. This account was of the type known as a Totten Trust; Marie Flohr was trustee, and she had reserved to herself the right to withdraw any or all of the funds at any time. Her son was named as beneficiary.

Empire responded to the writ of garnishment by stating that Marie Flohr was trustee of the trust account, and that the trust funds were not subject to garnishment. Jacob Flohr traversed Empire’s response. Subsequently, but before trial, Empire allowed Marie Flohr to withdraw all of the funds in the account. The court concluded that Empire was liable to Jacob Flohr in the amount of $6,200, the amount in the trust account at the time of service of the writ of garnishment.

I.

We must first consider Jacob Flohr’s contention that this court does not have jurisdiction to hear this appeal because Empire failed to file a sufficient memorandum brief in support of its motion for new trial. We disagree.

The requirement of a memorandum brief is for the benefit of the trial court in its review of its determination of the case. Where, as here, the trial court obviously considered the brief to be sufficient and considered the brief in its ruling on the motion, the brief has fulfilled its purpose as intended by the rules of procedure. Thus, this court does have jurisdiction, and the judgment is properly before the court for review.

See L.C. Fulenwider, Inc. v. Ginsberg,

36 Colo.App. 246, 539 P.2d 1320 (1975).

II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.