Washington Supreme Court July 28, 1983, 49238-7 (Schuh v. Department of Ecology)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-1983

Rosellini, J.

Respondent, Robert L. Schuh, sought permission to transfer a groundwater right to a new location. The Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB) denied permission, the Superior Court reversed and the Court of Appeals affirmed. We hold that the trial court erred in vacating the decision of the PCHB and reverse.

This dispute arose from the following facts. Respondent, like many farmers in Eastern Washington, would like to irrigate his 160-acre farm by tapping into existing groundwater supplies. His farm lies south of 1-90 between George and Moses Lake. Rather than applying for a permit of his own (behind 213 other applicants), respondent purchased the rights to an existing permit from a James Redwine. That permit was appurtenant to Mr. Redwine's farm which lay 5 miles northeast of that owned by respondent.

The permit purchased by respondent was originally owned by the previous owner of Redwine's farm, a gentleman by the name of Albin O. Pederson. Mr. Pederson applied for the permit on December 17, 1949. In response to the application, the State Department of Conservation and Development, Division of Hydraulics, predecessor to the Department of Ecology (DOE), issued groundwater permit 1221 on June 12, 1950. Certificate of Ground Water Right 888A was issued on November 30, 1951.

At the time the certificate was issued, the United States Bureau of Reclamation was completing the facilities necessary to deliver water pursuant to the Columbia Basin Project. The project started delivering irrigation water to

*182

the lands in this area in 1957 and continues this service through today.

Mr. Pederson's farm is located within the Columbia Basin and is thus eligible for service by the federal project. He was informed of this fact when he applied for the permit.

Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.