Idaho Court of Appeals December 27, 1983, 14227, 14325 (R.T. Nahas Co. v. Hulet)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-12-1983
WALTERS, Chief Judge.
Jay and Gertrude Hulet (hereinafter referred to as Hulet) appeal from a judgment recognizing the prior right of R.T. Nahas Co. and Robert and Eva Nahas (hereinafter referred to as Nahas) to divert winter runoff water from Sinker Creek, a tributary of the Snake River, located in Owyhee County, Idaho. Hulet presents ten issues which can be consolidated into six contentions, as follows. (1) Hulet’s motion to dismiss, for failure to name the Department of Water Resources as a party, was improperly denied. (2) Several findings of fact concerning the size of Nahas’ appropriation are not supported by substantial competent evidence. (3) The award of costs to Nahas against Hulet in the amount of the fee for Nahas’ expert witness was improper. (4) The court should not have ordered that Hulet be responsible for costs incurred in the future by Nahas, in enforcing Nahas’ water rights. (5) Nahas’ appropriation for livestock water rights should not have been recognized because there was no physical diversion of water. (6) Neither actual nor punitive damages should be awarded in this case.
Additionally, Nahas seeks an award of attorney fees for representation on this appeal. We affirm the judgment of the court below in part, modify in part and remand for additional findings. We also deny recovery of attorney fees, on appeal, by Na-has.
The following facts are undisputed. In 1969, Nahas purchased over 1,000 acres of ranch land. On the land was a lake which was filled by means of a diversion from Sinker Creek and from which was pumped water for irrigation of a small part of the ranch. Although Nahas’ predecessor in interest had applied for licensed water permits for diversion to the lake and for pumping from it, it appears that these permit rights were never perfected. Nahas based his claimed irrigation water rights on the constitutional method of appropriation — diversion and application to beneficial use.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit