Court of Appeals of North Carolina April 5, 1983, 8215SC391 (Lloyd v. Carnation Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1983
combined-opinion
301 S.E.2d 414 (1983) Ben LLOYD v. CARNATION COMPANY, Gary Willier, and Warren Manuel. No. 8215SC391. Court of Appeals of North Carolina. April 5, 1983. *415 Powe, Porter & Alphin by Charles R. Holton and Edward L. Ball, Durham, for plaintiff-appellant. Smith, Moore, Smith, Schell & Hunter by Jack Floyd, Frank J. Sizemore, III, and Jeri L. Whitfield, Greensboro, for defendants-appellees. BRASWELL, Judge. The focal point of the facts concerns a verbal contract of 1967 vintage through which the plaintiff allegedly became an exclusive territorial distributor of bull semen for Carnation Company. It is crucial, given the history of the case, that we examine procedure before substance in our analysis. When the complaint was filed on 18 April 1979, there were three defendants: Carnation Company, Gary Willier and Warren Manuel. The complaint contains seven counts for relief. The first five counts are designated as against defendant Carnation only: (1) Unfair Trade Practice, (2) Unlawful Price Maintenance, (3) Breach of Contract, (4) Unjust Enrichment, and (5) Fraud. Counts Six and Seven are against the defendants Willier and Manuel only. Count Six is for Conspiracy to Commit Unfair Trade Practices. Count Seven is for Unlawful Interference With Contractual Rights. Defendants filed a joint Answer on 22 June 1979, which alleges eleven defenses and which was amended to include a twelfth defense on 19 December 1980. Defendants moved for summary judgment on all counts on 4 September 1979, and plaintiff filed cross-motion for partial summary judgment on 23 October 1980. By order dated 1 January 1981, filed 12 January 1981, the trial judge having held evidentiary hearing, allowed defendants' motion for summary judgment on Counts Five, Six and Seven, but denied it as to Counts One, Two, Three, and Four. There was no appeal.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit