Alaska Supreme Court June 17, 1983, 5762, 5815 (Earth Resources Co. of Alaska v. State, Department of Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-1983

AMENDED OPINION

BURKE, Chief Justice.

This case involves principles of multistate corporate taxation as set out in the Multistate Tax Compact, AS 43.19.010-43.19.050 and the Alaska Net Income Tax Act, AS 43.20.010-43.20.350 (ANITA). The central issue on appeal is whether the taxpayer was properly found to be a unitary business to which the apportionment formula of AS 43.20.065 must be applied. Additionally, the taxpayer raises questions regarding the standard of review and the burden of proof to be utilized when a taxpayer challenges the Department’s application of the apportionment formula.

1

*963

The Earth Resources Company (ERC or “parent”) is a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in Dallas, Texas. As a diversified company, it owns and operates several enterprises directly or through subsidiary corporations. One of its wholly owned corporations is the Earth Resources Company of Alaska, Inc. (ERCA or “taxpayer”).

2

During the tax years 1974-1976,

3

ERCA filed its Alaska Corporate Net Income Tax Returns using the separate accounting method and reporting 100% of its income in Alaska. The Department rejected this accounting procedure and calculated ERCA’s tax liability by applying the apportionment formula of AS 43.20.065.

4

Utilization of the formula resulted in a $371,706.00 tax deficiency.

5

ERCA challenged the additional assessment before a full Department hearing held on November 7, 1978. The Department’s ruling of September 25, 1979, rejected the taxpayer’s contentions and ordered payment of the disputed tax liability. ERCA then appealed the Department’s decision to the superior court. The superior court in a memorandum of decision dated January 7, 1981, ruled that substantial evidence existed to support the Department’s decision and affirmed the Department’s ruling. Notice

*964

of appeal to this court was filed by the taxpayer on January 14, 1981. Notice of cross-appeal was filed by the Department on February 2, 1981.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.