Supreme Court of Connecticut May 24, 1983, 9760 (Reynolds v. Soffer)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-05-1983
Speziale, C. J.
This appeal concerns whether a right of way exists as claimed by the defendants, Jacob Soffer and Joseph Soffer, across land owned by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs brought an action in three counts seeking, inter alia: (1) a declaratory judgment determining whether the defendants had a right of way over the plaintiffs’ property and, if so, defining its scope; (2) an injunction against the defendants’ use of the claimed right of way and damages for past use; and (3) a judgment quieting title in the plaintiffs. The defendants filed an answer and counterclaim asserting their ownership of the right of way and seeking damages for interference with it by the plaintiffs.
1
The trial court found that no right of way or easement existed in favor of the defendants over the plaintiffs’ property either by express grant or by prescription. The defendants have appealed to this court claiming, inter alia, that the evidence established a prescriptive easement in their favor and that the court erred when it inferred that the defendants’ use was permissive.
2
We agree.
The trial court found the following facts: Louis Soffer, the defendants’ father and predecessor in in
*186
terest, purchased two lots from the town of Branford in 1923. One lot contains eight acres and is referred to as the “first piece”; the other lot is twenty-two acres and is referred to as the “second piece.” These two pieces of land are entirely separated from each other by an eighteen acre tract of land, once owned by Ruel Blackstone, which was bought by the plaintiffs from the heirs of Blackstone on December 15, 1970.
The town of Branford had used the two parcels as the town poor farm for many years. The farm residents lived on the first piece and farmed the second piece. They would regularly walk and drive farm machinery from the first to the second piece along a path that crossed the Blackstone property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit