Texas Court of Appeals, 5th District (Dallas) December 28, 1983, 05-82-00760-CV (Fuller v. Preston State Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-1983

GUITTARD, Chief Justice.

This suit concerns the validity of a vendor’s deed of trust lien arising from the sale of a homestead. Ethel D. Fuller, individually and as community administratrix of the estate of J.B. Fuller, sued Preston State Bank to cancel the lien. She alleged that the conveyance by her and her late husband to their son and his wife was a simulated transaction made for the purpose of obtaining a loan from the bank and fixing a lien on the homestead, contrary to the prohibition in article XVI, section 50 of the Texas Constitution. She also sought damages from the bank, its loan officer, and a title company attorney under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, TEX.BUS. & COM.CODE §§ 17.41-17.45 (Vernon Supp.1982-1983). The trial court instructed a verdict for all defendants, and plaintiff appeals. We hold that the evidence raises fact issues as to whether the bank had knowledge or notice that the sale was simulated. We also hold that plaintiff was not a “consumer” with respect to the bank within the Deceptive Trade Practices Act and that she was not adversely affected by any alleged deceptive trade practice within the Act. Consequently, we reverse the judgment insofar as it denies the claim for cancellation of the lien and remand that claim for trial, but otherwise we affirm. In view of another trial, we also rule on points complaining of the exclusion of certain evidence.

1.

Validity of Lien

We first consider whether there was sufficient evidence to go to the jury on the validity of the lien. In 1977 J.B. and Ethel Fuller owed more than $22,000 to Preston State Bank and were threatened with bankruptcy. They occupied as their homestead a house in Duncanville. In October of that year they conveyed the property to their son John and his wife Brenda. John and Brenda paid nothing in cash, although the closing papers recite a cash payment of $15,000. They signed a promissory note for $50,000 payable to Preston State Bank and a deed of trust to secure it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.