Supreme Court of Iowa October 19, 1983, 68478 (Fonken v. Community Church of Kamrar)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-10-1983

combined-opinion

339 N.W.2d 810 (1983) Doris FONKEN, Alvin Van Langen, Lester Klaver, et al., Appellees, v. COMMUNITY CHURCH OF KAMRAR, Hamilton County, Iowa, et al., Appellants. No. 68478. Supreme Court of Iowa. October 19, 1983. *812 W.K. Doran of Doran, Doran, Courter & Quinn, Boone, for appellants. James L. Kramer and Thomas J. Bice of Johnson, Erb, Latham & Gibb, P.C., Fort Dodge, for appellees. Larry J. Cohrt of Swisher & Cohrt, Waterloo, and Timothy Belz of Young & Belz, Clayton, Mo., for amicus curiae the membership of Colfax Center Presbyterian Church. Considered en banc. McCORMICK, Justice. It is a paradox that disputes among church members, like disputes in families, can become emotional and bitter despite the high motives and essential decency of the people involved. When a schism occurs, the civil courts are sometimes asked to decide which faction is entitled to the property owned by the church. As the present case illustrates, the decision is difficult when church interests in property are not established through traditional legal instruments. The trial court held that title to the local church property was subject to an implied trust in the general church. On defendants' appeal from the decree for plaintiffs, we affirm. We also affirm on plaintiffs' cross-appeal from the trial court's order keeping defendants in possession of the property before the appeal was taken. The role of civil courts in resolving church property disputes is affected by decisions of the United States Supreme Court construing the impact of the free exercise and establishment clauses of the first amendment of the federal Constitution. Because these decisions set the constitutional limits of state court inquiry, we first briefly summarize their holdings. The starting point is Watson v. Jones, 80 U.S. (13 Wall.) 679, 20 L.Ed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.