Court of Appeals of Arkansas October 19, 1983, CA 82-501 (Sterling v. Landis)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-10-1983

George K. Cracraft, Judge.

The sole question presented by this appeal is whether parol evidence is competent to establish an oral modification of agreements contained in an instrument required to be in writing by the Statute of Frauds when offered by a stranger to the written instrument. We hold that it is.

Clifton Sterling brought this action to recover treble damages from Johnny Landis for wrongfully cutting and removing standing timber from his land without his consent. He had also initiated criminal proceedings against Landis based on that incident. Landis admitted that he had cut the timber but asserted that the cutting had been authorized by Lizzie Mae Sterling under an oral agreement she had with Clifton Sterling giving her that right. Landis counterclaimed against Sterling to recover damages for malicious prosecution based on the criminal proceedings. The j ury found all issues against Sterling and j udgmen t was entered for Landis on his counterclaim. Sterling appeals from that judgment contending that the trial court erred in not excluding evidence of a parol modification of the terms of a prior written instrument. We do not agree.

The record discloses that E. D. Sterling died in 1965 owning and occupying as his homestead a tract of land from which the timber was cut. He was survived by his widow, Mae Sterling, and fourteen children, one of whom was the appellant, Clifton Sterling. By several separate deeds executed in 1968 the appellant acquired all the interest, both of Mae Sterling and of his brothers and sisters, in the property. Some, but not all, of the conveyances contained the following reservation:

It is understood that our mother Lizzie Mae Sterling may live in the house as long as she wishes, provided the pays the taxes on the estate and keeps the buildings, and pasture fences, as long as the land is used for pasture, in as good a state of repairs as they are in now.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.