United States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. Wisconsin September 15, 1983, 3-19-10053 (Flake v. People's State Bank of Mazomanie (In Re Flake))

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1983

MEMORANDUM DECISION

ROBERT D. MARTIN, Bankruptcy Judge.

In this adversary proceeding, People’s State Bank of Mazomanie and Triple S Feeds, Inc., object to certain of the exemptions claimed by the wife in a joint chapter 7 petition filed by a farming couple. The substance of the creditors’ objection is that Mrs. Flake has insufficient ownership interest in the farm implements she claims as exempt to be entitled to avoid liens on the equipment under 11 U.S.C. § 522(f). The

*276

creditors similarly object to the debtor’s claim for exemption of 3 items on the grounds that the implements claimed do not fall within the scope of the Wisconsin exemptions statute.

1

On her schedule of exemptions, Mrs. Flake claimed,

inter alia,

an “IHC # 46 baler with thrower” under the exemption for “one binder;” a “324 New Idea 2 row corn picker” under the exemption for “one corn binder;” and an “Allied 48' bale elevator” for the exemption of a “hay loader.” Upon the testimony of the debtors and expert witnesses for both sides, and the briefs of counsel, I am satisfied that the creditors’ objections to the exemptions claimed in the IHC baler, Allied bale elevator and New Idea corn picker must be sustained. The evidence shows that these implements are not in fact the binder, hay loader and corn binder provided for in the Wisconsin exemptions statute. Each of the farm implements identified in the statute was different in character and performed a substantially different function in the harvesting of crops than the implements claimed exempt. There was no evidence presented from which I can find that the modern implements of the debtors are the direct successors in farm operations to the now rarely used implements of the statute.

The arguments concerning the extent of Mrs. Flake’s legal interest in the farm implements were considered in the decision denying summary judgment in this proceeding. That decision pointed out the possibility that evidence could be adduced to demonstrate that Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.