United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts October 28, 1983, 15-14553 (Martha's Vineyard Cooperative Bank v. Andrews (In Re Andrews))
Also known as
United States · · · 28-10-1983
*971
MEMORANDUM
JAMES N. GABRIEL, Bankruptcy Judge.
The Complaint of the Plaintiff, Martha’s Vineyard Cooperative Bank, (“the bank”) seeks a determination that two unsecured loans totalling $3700 it granted the debtors, Bradford and Susan Andrews (“the debtors” or “the Andrews”) are nondischargeable pursuant to 11 U.S.C. Section 523(a)(2)(B). A trial was held on November 16, 1982. Based upon the agreed facts, testimony and the documentary evidence the Court finds the following facts.
In May 1980 the debtor, Bradford Andrews, obtained a loan application from the bank to apply for a mortgage loan. The debtor, Susan Andrews, prepared the application dated August 29, 1980 which sought a mortgage loan of $45,000 on Lot 25 Canterbury Lane, Vineyard Haven, Massachusetts. On page one of the application the debtors checked off the question “are you buying?”, indicated a purchase price of $12,-000, and that they were “building”. The testimony of the only bank employee to testify, Mrs. Conroy, was that the bank knew the Andrews owned the Canterbury Lane property and that the Andrews were building a home at this location. On the second page of the application the Andrews gave their current address as Greenwood Ave., Vineyard Haven, and indicated that they rented these premises. The application stated that Mr. Andrews’ monthly income as a mason contractor was $2500 to $3000. The application listed a checking account at the “M.V. National Bank”. The application did not request a statement of assets or secured debt. Rather, with respect to liabilities, the application only requested a list of “monthly obligations and open accounts”. The Andrews listed total monthly obligations of $316.18, owed to four creditors — Ford Motor Credit, Sears, Alden’s and Martha’s Vineyard Cooperative Bank. The application was submitted to the bank and in early September, Mrs. Con-roy notified Mr. Andrews that a loan of $45,000 would not be approved, but that a loan of $40,000 would be considered.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit