Michigan Court of Appeals April 20, 1983, Docket 66423 (People v. McCune)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-04-1983
E. A. Quinnell, J.
Defendant is charged with 12 felonies arising out of five separately alleged conspiracies and robberies or breakings and enterings. The cases are pending in the Kent County Circuit Court on five separate informations. Over the objection of the prosecution, the circuit court granted the defendant’s motion to consolidate the five in-formations for a single trial. The propriety of the consolidation order is before this Court on the prosecutor’s appeal by leave granted.
The prosecution claims that consolidation was improvidently ordered because the cases involve
*102
five separate incidents at four separate locations over a time span of nearly five months.
The defendant claims that he had worked for several years as an undercover agent for the Grand Rapids Police Department Vice Squad and was employed during the time involved as a police officer in the Grand Rapids City Parks Department. He claims that, to the extent that he was involved in the robberies of certain drug houses (places where illicit drugs are sold), he was acting as an undercover agent to gain additional information regarding drug activity, which he dutifully turned over to the Deputy Chief of the Grand Rapids Police Department. He denies any criminal intent with regard to his participation in the offenses charged and claims that such participation was part of a common scheme or plan to generate additional information for the benefit of the Grand Rapids Police Department.
Determining the propriety of consolidation in the case at bar requires a two-step analysis. We must first determine whether the offenses involved are of a type subject to the trial court’s discretionary power to consolidate, and, if so, we must then decide whether the court properly exercised its discretion under all of the facts and circumstances of this case.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit