California Court of Appeal October 4, 1983, Civ. 5934 (Roberts v. Gulf Oil Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-1983

Opinion

ANDREEN, J.

We are called upon to decide to what extent a county tax assessor may compel disclosure of interpretative data from taxpayers.

Pursuant to Revenue and Taxation Code section 468

1

plaintiff Kern County Assessor Herbert E. Roberts (Assessor) secured a subpena duces tecum compelling defendant Gulf Oil Corporation (Gulf), through one of its employees,

2

to appear in court, answer questions concerning certain properties owned by Gulf and to produce records concerning same. Gulf then moved to modify, limit or quash the subpena duces tecum and for protective orders. After a hearing on the motions, the trial court ordered an evidentiary hearing.

I. Evidentiary Hearing

In 1977 and 1978, Gulf acquired oil and gas properties located in Kern County. By written request the Assessor asked for, but was denied, information relating to the acquisitions. The request was for raw data, such as measurements of oil gravity, and for interpretative data, such as an isopachous map of the net sand on the productive zones, any report or study on fire-flood projects to be carried out on some of the newly acquired properties and studies of other enhanced recovery projects on others.

At the hearing, Gulf conceded that it was required to furnish raw data, but not what it termed interpretative data. Gulf acknowledges that it was obligated to furnish the following information:

“a. Cumulative Oil Production

“b. Depth to Top of Zone [at well]

“c. Oil Gravity

“d. Original Reservoir Pressure [measured]

*776

“e. Current Reservoir Pressure [measured]

“f. Reservoir Temperature [measured]

“g. Oil Viscosity

“h. Permeability to Air [measured]

“i. Porosity [measured]

“j. Saturation (% of oil, gas and water) [measured]

“k. Oil Saturation Before Bum

“1. Oil Saturation After Burn

“m. Oil Characteristics on Distillation

“n. Unit Agreements

“o. Property Acquisition Data (i.e., sales price, terms, sales agreement, parties, description of property and interests acquired)

“p.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.