California Court of Appeal April 26, 1983, Civ. 52048 (Buran Equipment Co. v. H & C INVESTMENT CO.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-04-1983

Opinion

KING, J.

In this case we hold that section 9504 of the California Uniform Commercial Code does not require a secured creditor to repossess the security prior to giving a notice of private sale, in order to obtain a deficiency judgment against a debtor who is in default.

Buran Equipment Company, dba Bay Area Kenworth Company (Buran) appeals from a judgment in favor of H & C Investment Company, Inc., a California corporation and Great Western Agrinomics, a Nevada partnership, etal. (H & C) after a nonjury trial. We reverse the judgment.

The dispute here involves an issue of law which makes a detailed recitation of the facts unnecessary. Buran sold H & C a considerable number of pieces of heavy vehicular equipment which were security for the payment of a promissory note from H & C to Buran. H & C thereafter defaulted on the note.

Buran gave a timely notice of private sale pursuant to California Uniform Commercial Code section 9504, subdivision (3), which permits a secured party, after a default, to sell the collateral in a commercially reasonable manner, conditional upon giving the defaulting party “. . . a notice in writing ... of the time on or after which any private sale ... is to be made.”

Some of the vehicles were not repossessed by Buran until eight months after the notice of sale. Buran sold the vehicles between six and eighteen months

*341

after the date of the notice of sale. Thereafter a deficiency existed between the balance due on H & C’s note to Buran and the amounts recovered by Buran from the private sales, and this action to recover a deficiency judgment resulted.

Counsel stipulated at oral argument before this court that the trial court’s decision was based on its interpretation that section 9504 required Buran to repossess all of the security prior to giving a notice of private sale, in order to obtain a deficiency judgment. H & C contends this correctly reflects the law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.