Michigan Court of Appeals July 11, 1983, Docket 63903 (Berger v. Mead)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1983

Per Curiam.

Occasionally, we on this Court find some opinions difficult to write. A party’s injury can so strongly call for compensation that we feel strongly inclined to at least allow the case to go before a jury. Unfortunately, as in this case, the law is too clear on the subject. The Legislature has clearly pre-empted this area thus giving us very little leeway.

This is the second time this case is before this Court. The first time, the trial judge had dismissed the complaint against all defendants based on the Worker’s Disability Compensation Act’s exclusive remedy provision and on governmental immunity. In a split opinion, this Court held that some of the nondefaulting defendants were in fact entitled to governmental immunity. However, the judgment entered against the defendants in the present suit based on the Worker’s Disability Compensation Act was reversed and the case remanded.

Berger v City of Berkley,

87 Mich App 361; 275 NW2d 2

*212

(1978). The Supreme Court denied leave. 406 Mich 969 (1979).

1

On remand, after discovery was concluded, the trial court once again entered summary judgment for the remaining seven nondefaulting defendants based on the Worker’s Disability Compensation Act. MCL 418.131; MSA 17.237(131). Plaintiffs again appeal as of right.

Plaintiffs first argue that this Court’s first opinion precluded the trial court from entering summary judgment on this issue in this case. See

CAF Investment Co v Saginaw Twp,

410 Mich 428, 454-455; 302 NW2d 164 (1981). Although three opinions were filed, all three judges agreed on the workers’ compensation issue. Judge Allen’s opinion stated:

"This author and Judge Bronson, who writes separately, concur in the opinion of Judge T. M. Burns except [the part dealing with governmental immunity]. * * * In all other respects we agree with Judge Burns’s opinion.

1

87 Mich App 367.

In remanding on the workers’ compensation issue, Judge T. M.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.