Supreme Judicial Court of Maine December 15, 1983 (Mutton Hill Estates, Inc. v. Town of Oakland)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1983

GLASSMAN, Justice.

The Town of Oakland, the Oakland Planning Board, and the Oakland Board of Appeals appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court, Kennebec County, vacating and reversing the Planning Board and Board of Appeals’ denials of an application for subdivision approval submitted by Mutton Hill Estates, Inc., and remanding for the approval of such application. We affirm the Superior Court’s finding that the appellants violated Mutton Hill’s right to due process by unlawful preparation of the findings of facts supporting denial of Mutton Hill’s application. However, because of this violation, there is no determination of the merits of Mutton Hill’s application. We therefore vacate the Superior Court’s order reversing the appellants’ denial of Mutton Hill’s application, and remand the case to that court for its determination whether Mutton Hill’s proposal complies with local ordinances and state law.

I.

In 1979 Mutton Hill Estates, Inc., pursuant to 30 M.R.S.A. § 4956, first sought approval from the Oakland Planning Board of its plan to develop a twelve-lot residential subdivision off the McGrath Pond Road in Oakland. Although the proposal was given preliminary approval, and the Department of Environmental Protection reviewed and approved it, the Planning Board, by a 3 to 2 vote, refused to grant final approval of the plan. A timely appeal was filed with the Oakland Board of Appeals. The June 2, 1980 decision of the Board of Appeals stated:

Now therefore, Appellant’s appeal is denied in so far as it argues that the Oakland Planning Board was required by the Subdivision Ordinance to grant Final Approval because of its conditional Preliminary Approval or because of any es-toppel argument and Appellant’s appeal

*991

is granted on the ground that at the time of its denial of Final Approval the Oakland Planning Board made no written findings of fact establishing that the proposed subdivision did not meet the requirements of the Subdivision Ordinance and 30 M.R.S.A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.