Supreme Court of Connecticut July 26, 1983, 11059 (West Hartford Taxpayers Assn., Inc. v. Streeter)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1983

Parskey, J.

This is an action brought, inter alia, against the mayor and members of the town council of West Hartford seeking an order by way of mandamus or mandatory injunction compelling the defendants to call an election for the adoption or rejection of an initiative petition limiting increases in the town budget. The trial court rendered a judgment for the defendants and the plaintiffs have appealed. The trial court ruled that the initiative provisions of the charter could not be utilized for budgetary matters. We agree.

The appeal raises three issues: (1) whether it is appropriate for a court to inquire into the validity of an initiative proposal which has satisfied the mandatory statutory requirements for submission to the electorate; (2) whether the West Hartford charter precludes an initiative on budgetary matters; and (3) whether the rights of the electorate under the initiative provisions of the West Hartford charter constitute a limitation on the powers of the town council in budgetary matters.

I

We first consider the plaintiffs’ claim that in determining whether to issue a writ of mandamus

1

the court

*738

should not have considered the validity of the initiative proposal. Under chapter XI, § 1

2

of the town charter the electors have the power to propose to the council, with certain exceptions not pertinent to this case, any ordinance or other measure. Section 2

3

provides that if the proposed ordinance contains the requisite number of signatures and if the council fails to adopt such ordinance or measure within sixty days after the petition is filed with the town clerk the electors may adopt or reject the proposal at an election called and warned by the council within ninety days after the town clerk certifies to the council that the petition meets the charter requirements. Acting under these provisions the plaintiffs submitted to the town clerk a proposed ordinance limiting increases in the annual town budget.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.