District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania April 8, 1983, Civ. A. 82-2931 (Pearl v. Allied Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-04-1983

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

TROUTMAN, District Judge.

Complaining that the installation of urea formaldehyde insulation in their residences

*401

has generally resulted in property damages and a diminution in the fair market value of their homes, plaintiffs, purportedly representing a class of similarly situated individuals, instituted this action seeking appropriate recompense from defendants, manufacturers of the allegedly dangerous product. The complaint also alleges that a second class of plaintiffs have or will suffer physical harm and unspecified injuries as a result of their exposure to urea formaldehyde insulation. Hence, plaintiffs purport to represent two discrete classes: “Class I” plaintiffs are those who have suffered

property damage

as a result of their use of the offensive insulation; “Class II” plaintiffs purportedly have suffered or will suffer a variety of

physical maladies

as a result of their urea formaldehyde exposures.

Defendants, moving to dismiss

1

, argue that Class I plaintiffs have suffered no

tort

injury and that Class II plaintiffs have failed to properly allege that they suffer from any presently detectable physical injury-

A brief procedural background is required to fully understand the position of the parties. This action was initially commenced in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County and, after the filing of an amended complaint, removed to this Court. Defendants then filed a motion to dismiss and, contemporaneously therewith, a motion to stay discovery pending our ruling on the former motion. Responding, plaintiffs moved to file a second amended complaint which, they assert, will moot out any perceived defect which may exist in the first amended complaint. Defendants, recognizing the liberal policy which favors amendment, argue that the proposed second amended complaint fails to cure the above described legal deficiencies.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.