Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit May 31, 1983, 81-1676 (Jose R.A. Duran v. Merit Systems Protection Board)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-05-1983

McWILLIAMS, Circuit Judge.

Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. § 7703(b)(1), Jose R.A. Duran appeals to this Court from a final decision of the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB), which decision affirmed an initial decision by the Denver Field Of

*1175

fice of MSPB, which, in turn, affirmed the suspension and removal of Duran by the Department of the Air Force from Duran’s employment at the United States Air Force Academy at Colorado Springs, Colorado. We affirm the decision of the MSPB.

As stated, the MSPB affirmed the initial decision of the Denver Field Office of the MSPB. The decision of the Denver Field Office of MSPB was based on a three-day evidentiary hearing, at which hearing Ms. Gail E. Skaggs served as the Presiding Official. Ms. Skaggs filed an eight-page, typewritten, single-spaced Initial Decision and Order, which is commendably thorough. Since the MSPB simply affirmed Ms. Skaggs’ initial decision, we are, in a sense, reviewing Ms. Skaggs’ decision. We are in accord with Ms. Skaggs’ decision as adopted and affirmed by the MSPB.

From the record we learn that Duran was employed as a Baker’s Helper, WG-5, at a cadet dining hall at the Air Force Academy at Colorado Springs, Colorado. A fellow employee in the cadet bake-shop was William Ziebolz, WG-8, who, on occasion, served as Duran’s supervisor. Over a period of time, friction developed between Duran and Ziebolz. When Duran reported Ziebolz for eating dining hall food in the “clipper room,” a prohibited activity, a confrontation between the two occurred. Both agreed to meet at an off-the-base location to further discuss their on-the-job differences. The testimony as to just what happened at this meeting was conflicting. Ziebolz testified that Duran, without provocation, attacked him with an 18"-pipe wrench. Duran testified that Ziebolz made the first move, and that he only used the pipe wrench in self-defense. In this regard, Ms. Skaggs found that Duran, and not Ziebolz, was the aggressor.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.