Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit September 12, 1983, 82-5897 (Pennwalt Corporation v. Durand-Wayland, Inc., Sunkist Growers, Inc., Non-Party)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-09-1983

EUGENE A. WRIGHT, Circuit Judge:

Sunkist Growers, Inc., a nonparty in the underlying action, appeals from a district court order that it pay $9,000 in attorney fees to Pennwalt Corporation for failure to comply with a subpoena duces tecum. We conclude that the sanction was not proper under Fed.R.Civ.P. 45, because Sunkist had objected to discovery of the subpoenaed material and the district court had not ordered it to comply. Nor had the district court held a hearing to consider Sunkist’s objections to the propriety and reasonableness of the fee award.

*493

FACTS

In the underlying action, Pennwalt sued Durand-Wayland, Inc. in the Northern District of Georgia for patent infringement.

1

Durand-Wayland counterclaimed, asserting ownership of the patent by assignment from Sunkist.

Sunkist formerly employed a co-inventor of the patent, George A. Mills, and contractually retained ownership of inventions developed during his employment. Durand-Wayland believed that Mills had developed a similar device as a Sunkist employee, giving Sunkist a claim to the patent. It obtained a quitclaim assignment of any interest Sunkist had in the patent, promising to reconvey to Sunkist any rights in the patent it acquired in the Georgia action.

As part of the Georgia proceedings, attorneys for both parties came to California. Pennwalt served Sunkist and Sunkist’s outside patent counsel, William Rieber, with subpoenas duces tecum, seeking documents from their files that it contended were relevant to the Georgia action.

2

Sunkist moved in the Central District of California to quash the subpoenas, arguing that they were overbroad, that much of the materia] sought was irrelevant, and that a protective order issued by the Georgia court was inadequate. The district judge denied the motion, saying:

The motion is denied without prejudice to the question of admissibility or produci-bility of the documents set forth in the subpoena duces tecum.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.