Supreme Court of Missouri February 23, 1983, No. 63730 (Anderson v. City of Joplin)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-1983

GUNN, Presiding Judge.

This appeal concerns a three percent gross rental receipts tax imposed on hotel-motel operators by the City of Joplin. The appellant hotel-motel operators (operators) were unsuccessful in their circuit court action seeking to have the taxing ordinance declared invalid and unenforceable1 and have appealed the trial court’s action. A construction of revenue laws is involved, placing jurisdiction of the appeal with this Court. Mo. Const, art. V, § 3.

The decision in this case turns on the question of whether the tax sought to be imposed is, in fact, an unsanctioned sales tax as opposed to its designation as a license tax.

We find that the tax in this instance is an invalid sales tax and reverse the judgment.

On September 15, 1980, the City Council of the City of Joplin passed Ordinance No. 80-147, designed to encourage tourism and other economic growth. The pertinent language of the Ordinance reads:

Every person engaged in the business of renting, leasing, or letting living quarters, sleeping accommodations, rooms or a part thereof, in connection with any hotel, motel, or tourist court, as hereinafter defined, shall pay to the City of Joplin a tax equal to three percent (3%) of the *728gross rental receipts derived from or paid by transient guests for sleeping accommodations, as hereinafter defined. This tax shall be in addition to the license fee or tax described in Section 19-31 of this Code.

The appellant-operators allege that the tax imposed, despite its appellation as a license tax, is in reality a sales tax which the city council has not submitted to the voters for their sanction as required by § 94.510, RSMo 1978. Their reasoning is that the receipts from room rents, not including state and local tax, constitute the base on which the tax is calculated.

We agree and declare Ordinance No. 80-147 to be an invalid sales tax.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.