Utah Supreme Court June 7, 1983, No. 18495 (Wayman v. Western Coal Carrier Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-06-1983

HALL, Chief Justice:

The issue presented by this writ of review is whether presbycusis, a loss of hearing generally associated with the aging process, is compensable by the Second Injury Fund. We conclude that it is not.

While in the employ of Western Coal Carrier Corporation, applicant C. Leon Wayman caught his toe in a cable and fell, injuring his hands, knees, left wrist and shoulder. He sought compensation for the injuries sustained, but made no claim for hearing loss. The matter was referred to a medical panel for review.1 The panel determined the percentage of permanent partial impairment of the whole body attributable to the industrial injury and previously existing conditions, which included an impairment of twelve percent for hearing loss. However, at the urging of the Second Injury Fund, in a supplemental report the medical panel acknowledged that it had not applied the statutory correction for presbycu-sis,2 and after having done so, found that the hearing impairment represented not twelve percent but zero percent of the whole body.

The administrative law judge adopted the findings of the medical panel as his own and declined to include in his award any sum for hearing loss attributable to presby-cusis. The Industrial Commission adopted the findings of the administrative law judge and approved the award. Hence, this review.

The applicant advances the same contentions here as were advanced before the Commission: 1) the statutory allowance for presbycusis has no application because no claim for hearing loss was filed; 2) the Second Injury Fund is liable for all impairments incurred prior to the industrial accident, regardless of cause; and 3) any doubt as to liability is to be resolved in favor of applicant.

U.C.A., 1953, § 35-2-62 specifically provides that no claim for compensation for hearing loss shall be paid unless it can be demonstrated that the claimant has been exposed to harmful industrial noise. In the instant case, such was not done.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.