Colorado Court of Appeals June 2, 1983, No. 82CA1077 (Montez v. Board of County Commissioners)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1983

STERNBERG, Judge.

Five county employees sued the Board of County Commissioners of Pueblo County for breach of contract. The trial court dismissed, holding that a C.R.C.P. 106 review of the decision rendered following their grievance hearing was their exclusive remedy. We reverse and remand for additional proceedings.

The plaintiffs were laid off from their jobs with the Board and Bridge Department of Pueblo County on or about January 14, 1981. Their relationship with the defendant had been governed by a union contract which expired December 31, 1980. This contract was not renewed, and there were no negotiations in progress. At the time of the layoffs there was a document known as the Pueblo County Personnel Policy in effect. On the subject of layoffs, the Policy stated that the provisions of the union contract “shall prevail.” The union contract required that layoffs and rehiring be effected strictly in accordance with seniority. However, other factors could be considered, and in the event these factors were taken into consideration, the decision was to be made by a committee consisting of union and county representatives.

The Policy provided a grievance procedure by which any employee could appeal to the department head any action believed to be in violation of the Policy. The depart ment head was authorized to hold a hearing and render a decision. It provided further that if the employee “still feels aggrieved he or she may ... have recourse to such judicial remedies as may be available.”

On March 2, 1981, certain employees who allegedly had less seniority than the plaintiffs were called back to work, and plaintiffs were not. Following the procedures in the Policy, plaintiffs filed grievances with defendants alleging a violation of their seniority rights.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.