New York Court of Appeals July 5, 1983 (People v. Hughes)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-07-1983
OPINION OF THE COURT
Wachtler, J.
The primary question on this appeal concerns the admissibility of a rape victim’s testimony when she has undergone hypnosis sometime prior to trial for the purpose of refreshing or restoring her memory of the incident. The trial court held that the pretrial use of hypnosis did not affect the admissibility of the victim’s testimony but only presented a credibility question for the jury. The Appellate Division reversed and ordered a new trial. The court held that hypnosis has not been generally accepted in the scientific community as a reliable method of restoring memory and that therefore the victim’s posthypnotic recollections should have been suppressed. The court noted however that on the new trial the victim could testify concerning events recalled prior to hypnosis. The prosecutor has appealed.
I
On the evening of May 19, 1978 a man broke into the victim’s Syracuse apartment, dragged her from her bed *527and raped her in the yard behind her home. During the attack she was choked and beaten. On June 8, 1978 the defendant was arrested and subsequently indicted for rape, assault and burglary in connection with the incident.
Prior to trial the defendant moved to suppress the victim’s identification. In support of the application he noted that the victim’s hospital records indicated that she was unable to recall what happened. It was also noted that after her release from the hospital the police had arranged for her to be hypnotized by a psychologist and under hypnosis she apparently was able to identify the defendant as her assailant. The defendant contended that hypnosis “has as its core and implementation a suggestibility” and that the victim’s identification was therefore unduly suggestive as a matter of law. In the alternative he requested a hearing pursuant to United States v Wade (388 US 218).
The trial court granted the motion to the extent of ordering that a hearing be held.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit