Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 10, 1983 (People v. Diaz)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-11-1983

lead-opinion

Judgments, Supreme Court, Bronx County (Ivan Warner, J.), rendered on December 7, 1981, unanimously affirmed. Concur — Fein, Milonas, Kassal and Alexander, JJ.

concurrence-opinion

Carro, J. P.,

concurs, in a memorandum as follows: Around 9 p.m. on New Year’s Eve Felix Diaz shot Luis Chavana in the abdomen, causing his death. At trial defendant took the stand and stated that he had originally encountered the deceased when Chavana had clumsily stepped on his foot, in a local grocery store. Some pushing and words were exchanged, but nothing further. A bit later, on a nearby street corner, defendant was standing talking to a former girlfriend when Chavana came up, cursing and yelling, “who has the fucking pela [heroin]?” Although the couple ignored Chavana for a few minutes, when the man reached into his coat pocket defendant pulled out a .38 Smith & Wesson and shot once. Mr. Diaz claimed that he saw a “bulge” in his victim’s coat, and further testified that his pistol was broken, so that when he drew the gun and began to cock it, the hammer slipped and the weapon discharged accidentally. However, the ballistics expert testified that the gun was not broken, was fully operable and possessed a mechanism preventing discharge unless the trigger was pulled. The defense presented no ballistics expert of their own to rebut this, even though given the opportunity to do so midway through the trial. Thus, I agree that the conviction should be affirmed because the evidence of appellant’s guilt was clearly and convincingly presented, with ample justification for the jury’s conclusion that Mr. Diaz intended to cause serious physical injury. (The jury, incidentally, inspected the weapon through its foreman.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.