New York Supreme Court March 23, 1983 (People v. Monaghan)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-03-1983
OPINION OF THE COURT
David O. Boehm, J.
Defendant’s prior motion to prohibit the use for any purpose, including cross-examination, of a statement impermissibly obtained from him after an arrest warrant had been issued was denied by this court (Pine, J.) on the basis of the District Attorney’s concession that it would not be used as evidence-in-chief (see People v Samuels, 49 NY2d 218). The court ruled that it could be used for purposes of impeachment, pursuant to Harris v New York (401 US 222). Defendant now makes this supplemental motion for the same relief, citing as new authority, United States v Brown (699 F2d 585).
New York State courts have consistently held that while an incriminating statement taken in violation of a defendant’s constitutional rights may not be introduced in evidence as part of the case of the prosecution, it is admissible to impeach a defendant who chooses to testify (see People v Ricco, 56 NY2d 320; People v Washington, 51 NY2d 214; *327People v Wise, 46 NY2d 321; People v Williams, 91 AD2d 1173; People v Guidice, 83 AD2d 756; People v Caban, 79 AD2d 1031).
Frequently cited in support of this rule is Harris v New York (supra), in which the Supreme Court held that statements obtained in violation of a defendant’s Miranda rights, while inadmissible as evidence-in-chief, may nevertheless be used to impeach the credibility of a defendant as long as the statements were not coerced or otherwise involuntary (see New Jersey v Portash, 440 US 450; Mincey v Arizona, 437 US 385; see, also, People v Caban, supra, p 1032). In Harris the court announced that the constitutional shield preventing illegally seized evidence from being used against a defendant at trial cannot be “perverted into a license to use perjury by way of a defense, free from the risk of confrontation with prior inconsistent utterances” (Harris v New York, supra, p 226; see, also, United States v Havens, 446 US 620, 626; Oregon v Hass, 420 US 714, 722-723).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit