New York Supreme Court March 17, 1983 (Harlington Realty Corp. v. Farmiloe-Burke Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-03-1983

lead-opinion

OPINION OF THE COURT

Memorandum.

Final judgment reversed, without costs, and final judgment of possession is directed to be granted in favor of landlord.

In this commercial holdover proceeding, tenant was granted an option to extend the lease for a period of five years on condition that the lease as extended would provide for payment of a specified increased rental. After the expiration of the lease, tenant remained in possession for some 17 months but continued to pay only the original rental. Under these circumstances, tenant failed to timely exercise the option (cf. 50 Am Jur 2d, Landlord & Tenant, § 1190).

dissent

Jones, J.

(dissenting). The record reveals that tenant took possession of the premises, a bar, in June, 1970 as assignee of a lease that was to expire on May 31, 1975. In November, 1970, tenant and the company that then owned the premises executed a rider in which the owner agreed to extend the lease for a period of four years at a rental rate of *412$375 per month. The rider further provided that the owner agreed to grant tenant an option to extend the lease for an additional five years commencing June 1, 1979 at a rental of $400 per month. The agreement did not provide that tenant was required to notify landlord of his election to exercise this option. On December 22, 1978 the present landlord purchased the premises.

Prior to June 1,1979, tenant gave no written notice of its election to exercise the option. After June 1, 1979, tenant remained in the premises. Landlord continued to demand and tenant continued to pay monthly rent of $375 through October, 1980. After service of a 30-day notice terminating the alleged month-to-month tenancy, landlord commenced the subject holdover proceeding.

At trial, tenant’s president testified that tenant had paid $18,500 for the bar and had invested about $32,000 in it over the years for improvements. Its failure to pay the extra $25 per month beginning with June, 1979 was a result of forgetfulness.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.