New York Supreme Court August 4, 1983 (Sanchez v. Sirmons)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-08-1983

OPINION OF THE COURT

Wallace R. Cotton, J.

Motion by the petitioner, Carmen Sanchez, to stay arbitration of a medical malpractice claim, demanded by the respondent, Meredith Sirmons, M.D., is granted.

The respondent is a medical doctor duly licensed to practice medicine in the State of New York. On June 28, 1980, he performed an elective abortion on the petitioner at his Manhattan office. Petitioner, alleging that she was the victim of an act of medical malpractice committed during the performance of the abortion, subsequently commenced a personal injury action against the respondent on July 20, 1982. Issue in the personal injury lawsuit was joined on September 13, 1982. However, on October 22, 1982, the named defendant therein, Dr. Sirmons, who is the respondent in the instant proceeding, served a demand for arbitration of the alleged medical malpractice dispute upon the plaintiff, Ms. Sanchez, the petitioner herein.

Dr. Sirmons’ demand for arbitration is predicated on paragraph 9 of the “Consent To Abortion” form which Ms. Sanchez had signed on the morning the abortion was *250performed. Paragraph 9 states that “I agree that any dispute or claim which I may have relating to the abortion or any related medical procedure or any consequences thereof shall be determined solely by arbitration under the auspices and pursuant to the rules and regulations of the American Arbitration Association.”

In response to Dr. Sirmons’ arbitration demand, the petitioner, Ms. Sanchez, moved to stay arbitration. The motion was heard by a court of co-ordinate jurisdiction which directed that the matter be referred to this court for the purpose of conducting a preliminary trial to determine “the validity and enforceability of the arbitration clause in question” (see order dated Jan. 17,1983 issued by the Hon. Irwin M. Silbowitz).

Based upon the credible testimony and documentary evidence adduced during the trial of the instant proceeding, I find that Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.