New York Supreme Court December 5, 1983 (In re the Arbitration between Cohen & Drexel Burnham Lambert, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1983
OPINION OF THE COURT
Bernard F. McCaffrey, J.
This is a proceeding by a customer against his former commodities futures broker. The American Arbitration Association (AAA) stated it could only appoint one arbitrator and had administratively appointed the other two.
The AAA is organized as an independent and impartial tribunal. The list of proposed arbitrators is prepared by the AAA and submitted to the parties so that they can select, in numerical order, their preferences.
The two arbitrators appointed by the AAA are, or were, in the commodities futures business. One arbitrator is an independent floor broker and a member of various exchanges, the same exchanges to which respondent holds memberships. The second arbitrator is president of a commodities futures fund and had been associated with various commodities futures brokers.
The AAA retained these arbitrators on the panel over claimant’s objections.
At the commencement of the first hearing of this arbitration, claimant’s attorney attempted to question these arbi*1010trators concerning their possible business and social connections with respondent. The arbitrators refused to permit such questions and declined to respond thereto.
Thus, the petitioner in effect contends that, standing alone without any showing of conflict or bias, the mere present affiliations of two of the panel members with the commodities industry constitutes a conflict or prejudice as to such person’s ability to hear petitioner’s arbitration claim. These circumstances alone result in a right to commence discovery into the personal and business affairs of these two panel members in search of some possible link to the respondent which could support a further application to this court to remove them from the panel.
The court finds that petitioner’s contentions are without merit. Each panel member’s industry background was set forth in prehearing disclosures and no connection with respondent was indicated.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit