District Court, N.D. Indiana November 8, 1983, No. H 83-309 (Riverdale Bank v. Dubois (In re Bugos))

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-1983

KANNE, District Judge.

This matter is before the court on the notice of appeal filed by the Riverdale Bank on March 24, 1983. As the bank and the trustee in bankruptcy have adequately briefed the issue raised by the appeal and the court does not feel that oral argument would be helpful the court hereby denies the bank’s motion for oral argument. Bankruptcy Rule 8012.

This appeal arises out of an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court wherein it was determined that the Riverdale Bank was an unsecured creditor of Richard Bur-gos. The parties agree1 that in August of 1979 Richard Burgos, a resident of Indiana, borrowed $65,000.00 from the Riverdale Bank, located in Illinois, to purchase a towing business, also located in Illinois, and as security for the loan assigned to the bank his interest in an Indiana land trust.2 The question presented to the bankruptcy court (and to this court) is whether the law of Indiana or the law of Illinois controls the perfection of the bank’s security interest.3

The reasoning underlying the bankruptcy court’s conclusion is contained in the following passage:

The debtor’s beneficial interest in the land trust is an interest in personal property. As such, the principle (sic) applicable to acquiring a security interest in personalty are those applicable to acquiring a security interest in a land trust.... Further, since an interest in a land trust qualifies as a intangible, the determination of a party’s secured status turns on the law of the state in which the debtor resides. In re Cowsert, 14 B.R. 340, (Bkrtcy.S.D.Fla.1981). Therefore, Indiana Law determines the status of the Bank’s security interest. Ind.Code Section 26-1-9-302(1), requires the filing of a financing statement to perfect all security interests unless the interest quali-fys (sic) for one of the subsequently listed exceptions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.