Indiana Supreme Court October 19, 1983, No. 1182S416 (Wininger v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-10-1983
PIVARNIK, Justice.
Defendant-appellant William W. Wining er was convicted of Theft, Ind.Code § 85-48-4-2 (Burns Supp.1982), at the conclusion of a jury trial in Lawrence County Court on April 22, 1982. Wininger was also found to «be a habitual offender and was sentenced to thirty-three (88) years imprisonment. He now appeals.
Wininger raises only two issues on appeal, concerning:
1) whether the trial court erred in failing to instruct the jury about the definition of specific intent;
2) whether the trial court erred in refusing the defendant's tendered instruction concerning the defense of voluntary intoxication.
The evidence most favorable to the State reveals that on January 11, 1982, the victim, Cletus Magill, was seated next to the defendant in a tavern in Bedford, Indiana. As they talked, Magill asked the defendant for a ride to another tavern. Defendant agreed and the two men walked into an alley where the defendant took Magill's bill*861fold and ran. The defendant was later apprehended with the billfold in his possession.
I
The defendant first argues that Final Instruction 9-A, concerning the defense of voluntary intoxication, incorrectly stated the law and served only to confuse the jury. Instruction 9-A reads as follows:
Voluntary intoxication is a defense only to the extent that it negates specific intent.
Voluntary intoxication does not excuse the offense; but intoxication may be so extreme that a person is incapable of forming or entertaining a specific intent.
The State has the burden of disproving this defense beyond a reasonable doubt.
Defense counsel argued that "specific intent" was not explained anywhere else in the instructions; he also urged the trial court to modify the instruction so that the jury would know theft is a specific intent crime.
We find that this issue has been waived. Although defense counsel objected to the instruction, he failed to tender an instruction curing the alleged defects.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit