Indiana Court of Appeals November 28, 1983, No. 1-483A108 (Carson v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-11-1983
RATLIFF, Judge.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
The petitioners-appellants, John Carson, Stuart Keane, and Motel Resorts, Ltd. (petitioners), appeal from a Clark County Court judgment denying their motion for the return of certain property seized by the Indiana State Police pursuant to a search warrant. We affirm.
FACTS
In 1979, Motel Resorts, Ltd., owners and operators of the Marriott Inn in Clarksville, Indiana, arranged to lease a Kentucky Derby Machine from John Carson and Stuart Keane for use in the Inn's Churchbill Downs lounge. As described by the petitioners, the machine consists of nine mechanical horses which race across a track when activated by a token. If the horse chosen by the player wins the race, the lucky patron receives additional tokens in accordance with the odds displayed by the machine for that particular race. The tokens, which could be purchased for 25 cents a piece, were redeemable for food in either of the Inn's two restaurants. They could not be redeemed for cash or liquor, however, and winning patrons were required to pay any sales tax in cash.
Prior to installing the machine, Carson conferred with the Clark County Prosecutor, the Clarksville Police Chief, and two Indiana State Police officers regarding its legality. Convinced that its use would not result in prosecution for violating state gambling laws, Carson installed the machine.
On December 14, 1981, the Clark County Court issued a warrant for a search of the Marriott Inn. This warrant was premised upon an affidavit filed by the Indiana State Police which stated, inter alia: "that the above described items [the machine and other related paraphernalia] are unlawfully possessed and subject to seizure because they are used in an illegal gambling operation contrary to IC 35-45-5-8." Record at 129. Following the machine's seizure, however, no criminal charges were brought against Carson, Keane, Motel Resorts, Ltd., or the Marriott Inn, prompting the parties to file a motion for its return.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit