Court of Appeals of Oregon January 12, 1983, WCB Nos. 80-01598, 80-04905; CA A22533 (Elliott v. Loveness Lumber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-01-1983
WARDEN, J.
Claimant appeals an order on reconsideration of the Workers’ Compensation Board that eliminated the 25 percent penalty that had been imposed on EBI Companies for unreasonably refusing to pay compensation.
Claimant suffered an on-the-job injury to his lower back on November 15, 1979, when his employer was insured by Argonaut Insurance Company. That injury was an aggravation of a previous injury incurred on June 22, 1978, while claimant was working for the same employer, but when the employer was insured by EBI Companies.1
After the 1979 injury, claimant was treated by Dr. Scheer. He initially filed a claim with Argonaut, which denied the claim, stating that it appeared that claimant’s back condition was the result of his earlier injury and not a new injury. Dr. Scheer then sent a letter to EBI informing them of the denial by Argonaut and asking that claimant’s file be re-opened because of the “re-injury/aggravation of pre-existing injury having occurred June 22, 1978.” EBI denied the claim, “due to the fact that you sustained new injury on November 15, 1979 * * * constituting a new claim.”
The referee determined that EBI was the responsible carrier, ordered it to accept the claim, awarded an attorney fee and assessed a 25 percent penalty for unreasonable refusal to pay compensation. See ORS 656.262(8). The Board initially affirmed the referee but, in an order on reconsideration, it eliminated the imposition of the 25 percent penalty for unreasonable refusal to pay compensation. It concluded that the information available to EBI on the date its denial was issued “was not then of sufficient quantity or quality to make its denial unreasonable.”
The Board pointed out that the current version of OAR 436-54-322 imposes a specific duty on an insurer to request designation of a paying agent when it appears that there is an issue of responsibility for an otherwise compensable condition.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit