Court of Appeals of Oregon May 25, 1983, 81-1738-G; CA A25383 (State v. Berman)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-05-1983
BUTTLER, P. J.
Defendant appeals his conviction for exceeding the possession limit for a game fish (to-wit: trout), assigning as errors (1) the denial of his motion to suppress evidence and (2) the trial court’s conclusion that it was a violation of the law to possess more than 20 fish at any given time regardless of when or where the fish were caught. We agree with defendant’s second assignment and reverse.
Defendant’s conviction resulted from a seizure of 76 trout stored in a frozen food locker that he shared with two other persons. Defendant contends that the fish were seized as a result of an unlawful search and that they should have been suppressed. Without detailing the facts or the arguments of the parties, it is sufficient to say that the police had sufficient information to suspect that defendant had been fishing for several months and had taken a large number of trout, which he was saving for a “fish feed.” After receiving that information, they persuaded the owner of the market where the locker was located to open it; they found 18 packages, each containing several fish. The fish were returned to the locker. Two days later, two officers contacted defendant in his trailer, and he invited them in. They advised defendant that they had heard he had a lot of fish and that they wanted to see how many he had in his possession. They were shown five fish in the refrigerator of the trailer. One of the officers said to defendant, “Let’s go down and count your fish at the locker.” Defendant agreed, driving his own car to the market, where he met the officers and opened the locker with his key. The fish were seized, and defendant was arrested. The search of the locker was with defendant’s consent; his motion to suppress was properly denied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit