Court of Appeals of Oregon July 6, 1983, 2-79; CA A20220 (Brady v. Bureau of Labor & Industries)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-07-1983

GILLETTE, P. J.

Petitioner, the prevailing party in Brady v. Bureau of Labor, 55 Or App 619, 639 P2d 673 (1982), seeks an award of attorney fees pursuant to the Oregon Administrative Procedures Act (APA).1 We deny the petition.

Our prior opinion in this case arose out of our review of an order entered by the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor (Commissioner) against petitioner, finding that he was guilty of an unlawful employment practice in that he had refused on the basis of sex to hire a job applicant, Lehde, as a dental assistant. Pivotal to the Commissioner’s order was the fact that, while Lehde’s application for a job was pending, petitioner had offered a job to one Alcock, a man whom the petitioner found to be less qualified than Lehde. Alcock had, however, previously worked for petitioner. We said,

“The one point requiring close scrutiny is petitioner’s challenge to the Commissioner’s finding that the attempted rehiring of Alcock establishes unlawful discrimination. Alcock, less qualified than Lehde, had first been hired before Lehde applied for a job; he was later laid off for lack of work. Still later, with Lehde’s job application pending, Alcock was offered a job again. He declined. We agree with petitioner that the fact of the offer of reemployment to Alcock, in light of the other facts the Commissioner found, does not necessarily establish unlawful discrimination.

“The Commissioner found that Alcock was laid off due to lack of work. There is no suggestion that he was not competent in the work. If Alcock was offered a job because of prior, satisfactory performance, the attempt to re-employ him after a layoff had a legitimate, non-discriminatory purpose, see Lewis and Clark College v. Bureau of Labor, [43 Or App 245, 602 P2d 1161, rev den 288 Or 667 (1979)] and that act alone cannot constitute unlawful discrimination.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.